{ "registry_rights": { "may": [ "store", "index", "link", "validate schema", "check evidence refs exist", "detect technical inconsistency" ], "may_not": [ "determine truth", "raise maturity", "derive verified from evidence count", "drop an unknown", "turn PARTIAL into success" ] }, "integrity_problems": [], "semantic_reconciliation": { "claims": 16, "pass": 16, "failures": [], "unexplained_transformations": [], "registry_derived_authority": [], "verdict": "PASS" }, "adjudications": { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "evidence_type": "adjudication_declarations", "content_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:39:42.879195+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.611833+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" }, "_law": "ProofRenderer renders existing truth and decides nothing; every value is copied from its source; raw_state and adjudicated_state may differ and both are kept", "generated_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "claims": [ { "claim_id": "identity.one_line", "claim_type": "identity", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "is", "object": "Give AstraNL one real thing you need changed. It coordinates the rest. AstraNL is the neutral coordination and evidence layer between intent and real-world execution. It connects existing systems, agents and organisations to the right real-world capability - human, company, machine, robot, stock, transport or service - and returns a typed record of what was actually observed, agreed, executed and settled.", "maturity": "CANON", "authority": "founder mandate 2026-09-04 (decision 133)", "observation_state": "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "rendered every canon cycle", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "evidence_type": "canon", "content_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "created_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.565402+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590811+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-4085c187e232a265", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "4085c187e232a2656ed955ae4b2c5f8de8e6b012e4cf4991527d82122d43d40a", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/external_convergence.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T18:59:35.333774+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590988+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T18:59:34.545989+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "a statement of what AstraNL is built to be; adoption and volume are separate claims" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "STATED", "adjudicated_state": "STATED", "state_source": "facts.canon.identity_one_line + external_convergence.release_state", "human": { "claim": "Tell AstraNL what needs to happen. It finds a real way to get it done and shows the evidence.", "trust_state": "Stated identity, rendered from canon; external copies verified: EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/external_convergence.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/identity.one_line/maturity", "source_value": "CANON", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "CANON", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/identity_one_line", "source_value": "Give AstraNL one real thing you need changed. It coordinates the rest. AstraNL is the neutral coordination and evidence layer between intent and real-world execution. It connects existing systems, agents and organisations to the right real-world capability - human, company, machine, robot, stock, transport or service - and returns a typed record of what was actually observed, agreed, executed and settled.", "claim_field": "object", "claim_value": "Give AstraNL one real thing you need changed. It coordinates the rest. AstraNL is the neutral coordination and evidence layer between intent and real-world execution. It connects existing systems, agents and organisations to the right real-world capability - human, company, machine, robot, stock, transport or service - and returns a typed record of what was actually observed, agreed, executed and settled.", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-4085c187e232a265", "source_sha256": "4085c187e232a2656ed955ae4b2c5f8de8e6b012e4cf4991527d82122d43d40a", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/external_convergence.json", "source_selector": "release_state", "source_value": "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/identity_one_line", "source_value": "Give AstraNL one real thing you need changed. It coordinates the rest. AstraNL is the neutral coordination and evidence layer between intent and real-world execution. It connects existing systems, agents and organisations to the right real-world capability - human, company, machine, robot, stock, transport or service - and returns a typed record of what was actually observed, agreed, executed and settled.", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "STATED", "transformation": "projection:stated_claim_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/identity_one_line", "source_value": "Give AstraNL one real thing you need changed. It coordinates the rest. AstraNL is the neutral coordination and evidence layer between intent and real-world execution. It connects existing systems, agents and organisations to the right real-world capability - human, company, machine, robot, stock, transport or service - and returns a typed record of what was actually observed, agreed, executed and settled.", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "STATED", "transformation": "projection:stated_claim_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 4, "previous_revision_hash": "d6a5041144d95f9ff00e8332c5bff0fa5ac162d351ac90bba87e152e62d74e1f", "claim_content_hash": "dff20d610d425359f0a96a9f26d4c9c58880d225ee1cfa63b34bdab324f8da6e" }, { "claim_id": "fee.coordination", "claim_type": "commercial_term", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "charges coordination fee", "object": { "pct": 1.0, "basis": "only on a paid, confirmed settlement (commitments.json money.fee_basis)" }, "maturity": "LIVE", "authority": "runtime/canon/commitments.json (founder)", "observation_state": "RESOLVED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "computed at render from effective-interval rules", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "evidence_type": "canon", "content_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "created_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.565402+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590811+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" }, { "evidence_id": "ev-api-fee", "evidence_type": "api", "content_sha256": null, "source_location": "https://astranl.com/coordination/fee?amount_eur=100", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "valid_from": "2026-09-01", "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "1.0%", "adjudicated_state": "1.0%", "state_source": "core/temporal_truth.resolve", "human": { "claim": "1% coordination fee - only on a paid outcome, in force since 2026-09-01", "trust_state": "Derived from the fee rule in force since 2026-09-01; the same rule answers on every surface", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/coordination/fee?amount_eur=100" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/fee.coordination/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "economics/coordination_fee_current_pct", "source_value": 1.0, "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "1.0%", "transformation": "projection:percent_string", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "economics/coordination_fee_current_pct", "source_value": 1.0, "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "1.0%", "transformation": "projection:percent_string", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "economics/_law", "source_value": "derived by core/temporal_truth.py at generation time from effective-interval rules; never hand-edited; recompute for any date from fee_schedule", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "RESOLVED", "transformation": "projection:resolver_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "f7b80d34d2007a3547888b2aa6179c8ac976d3b087d617aeda4344e0674ffae6", "claim_content_hash": "4101f9736e9336303c7465ae04f8b96c74e7109746649abcbc4a0a41429e08db" }, { "claim_id": "payment.custody", "claim_type": "money_semantics", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "never holds third-party funds", "object": "Client pays provider directly on a provider-owned rail; AstraNL stays outside the work-money flow and earns only the separate 1% coordination fee after confirmed settlement. Stripe is optional.", "maturity": "LIVE", "authority": "commitments.json money.custody + direct_business_bank rail + optional Stripe AH-DEST-1 adapter", "observation_state": "CONTRACT_PUBLISHED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "payment-truth.json generated 2026-09-21T04:49:55.146564+00:00", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-f5d44ae1489ec981", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "f5d44ae1489ec9811fc22de85a8b4e038033042788676a1f5f252dfdf22a2ffc", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/payment-truth.json", "created_at": "2026-09-21T04:49:55.149098+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.591246+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T04:49:55.146564+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "settled volume through this flow: see counters claim" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "CONTRACT", "adjudicated_state": "CONTRACT", "state_source": "payment-truth.json plain_language", "human": { "claim": "Client pays provider directly on a provider-owned rail; AstraNL stays outside the work-money flow and earns only the separate 1% coordination fee after confirmed settlement. Stripe is optional.", "trust_state": "A published contract that every surface renders from: not escrow, not insurance, not a wallet, not a payment institution", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/payment-truth.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/payment.custody/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/payment.custody/observation_state", "source_value": "CONTRACT_PUBLISHED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "CONTRACT_PUBLISHED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-f5d44ae1489ec981", "source_sha256": "f5d44ae1489ec9811fc22de85a8b4e038033042788676a1f5f252dfdf22a2ffc", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/payment-truth.json", "source_selector": "plain_language/en/short", "source_value": "Client pays provider directly on a provider-owned rail; AstraNL stays outside the work-money flow and earns only the separate 1% coordination fee after confirmed settlement. Stripe is optional.", "claim_field": "object", "claim_value": "Client pays provider directly on a provider-owned rail; AstraNL stays outside the work-money flow and earns only the separate 1% coordination fee after confirmed settlement. Stripe is optional.", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-f5d44ae1489ec981", "source_sha256": "f5d44ae1489ec9811fc22de85a8b4e038033042788676a1f5f252dfdf22a2ffc", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/payment-truth.json", "source_selector": "plain_language/_source", "source_value": "runtime/canon/commitments.json money.custody + Article 55 direct-business-bank rail + optional AH-DEST-1 Stripe rail", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "CONTRACT", "transformation": "projection:contract_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-f5d44ae1489ec981", "source_sha256": "f5d44ae1489ec9811fc22de85a8b4e038033042788676a1f5f252dfdf22a2ffc", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/payment-truth.json", "source_selector": "plain_language/_source", "source_value": "runtime/canon/commitments.json money.custody + Article 55 direct-business-bank rail + optional AH-DEST-1 Stripe rail", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "CONTRACT", "transformation": "projection:contract_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 6, "previous_revision_hash": "7122c195ce19aae70cb2ab969d354831ea29061315b45c11794e0f8de0085847", "claim_content_hash": "0c7e8aa51814b8fc3a5753c225b11bc0c1abbfc274363af3e07c99e658f9be99" }, { "claim_id": "volume.honest_zero", "claim_type": "counter", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "real coordination volume", "object": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "maturity": "LIVE_ZERO_VOLUME", "authority": "live counters", "observation_state": "OBSERVED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "canon cycle", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "evidence_type": "canon", "content_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "created_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.565402+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590811+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "zero is valid data; no traction is claimed" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "adjudicated_state": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "state_source": "facts.canon.honest_zero", "human": { "claim": "Real settled coordination so far: real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "trust_state": "Live counters, published as they are", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/press/" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/volume.honest_zero/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE_ZERO_VOLUME", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE_ZERO_VOLUME", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/volume.honest_zero/observation_state", "source_value": "OBSERVED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "OBSERVED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/honest_zero", "source_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "claim_field": "object", "claim_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/honest_zero", "source_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ad101e5b75351e7f", "source_sha256": "ad101e5b75351e7f8baa3ba9e8fad0cacdd66fb5bccdaa268c7af062d7cebe25", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/astranl-facts.json", "source_selector": "canon/honest_zero", "source_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "real external settled agent orders: read https://astranl.com/api/agent-hands/board and the sealed log; this canon never states a volume as an adjective", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "b2e44252298cdd272fd0e135714d267939df26fc66e3420c3873d4ae2c170ac3", "claim_content_hash": "de0731f0bd62f8347b14315ea9011f18a2487ca87e4ac2be1151b64e1682e322" }, { "claim_id": "interop.a2a", "claim_type": "protocol_compatibility", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "A2A 1.0 applicable mandatory compatibility tests", "object": { "raw_tck_result": "234 PASS / 1 FAIL", "adjudicated_result": "235/235 implementation-conformant", "build": "13c4c24da407fbdc", "tck_commit": "263b9cfaf16a554bdfb166a7ba5b67716e946349", "adjudication": "runtime/conformance/paced_must/ADJUDICATION_CORE-SEND-003.json", "closure": "runtime/conformance/paced_must/CONFORMANCE_END.json", "known_astranl_must_defects": 0, "rerun": "FORBIDDEN without a new causal reason" }, "maturity": "PILOT", "authority": "official a2aproject/a2a-tck at commit 263b9cfaf16a554bdfb166a7ba5b67716e946349", "observation_state": "CONFORMANCE_SUBSTANTIVELY_VERIFIED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "immutable build 13c4c24da407fbdc; rerun forbidden without a new cause", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e2fdb77127dc38bb", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "e2fdb77127dc38bb8c81d427f3da650c2fe3d2600533a5512be64f73e3c796e1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/protocol_conformance_receipt.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:09:35.174003+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.591337+00:00", "canon_epoch": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.591386+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-3c8812ad66dbc425", "evidence_type": "conformance_closure", "content_sha256": "3c8812ad66dbc425bc2fcb2f2b1a447269ebc35f7acaeefe4c5661496def0f17", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/runtime/conformance/paced_must/CONFORMANCE_END.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T18:56:41.334848+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.593473+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" }, { "evidence_id": "ev-ce04017513b0b061", "evidence_type": "adjudication", "content_sha256": "ce04017513b0b0619eccbacfc05f9e95287968d68f9cb0732c998c21d6dfbf25", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/runtime/conformance/paced_must/ADJUDICATION_CORE-SEND-003.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:09:35.172003+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.593793+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "proves protocol compatibility only; not adoption, demand, volume or autonomous execution", "streaming and push are not offered" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "234 PASS / 1 FAIL", "adjudicated_state": "235/235 implementation-conformant", "state_source": "protocol_conformance_receipt.a2a_terminal + p05_evidence_bundle.a2a_implementation", "human": { "claim": "A2A compatibility is substantively verified.", "trust_state": "Raw test result: 234 PASS / 1 FAIL. One failure was adjudicated as a harness expectation defect.", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/protocol_conformance_receipt.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/interop.a2a/maturity", "source_value": "PILOT", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "PILOT", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e2fdb77127dc38bb", "source_sha256": "e2fdb77127dc38bb8c81d427f3da650c2fe3d2600533a5512be64f73e3c796e1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/protocol_conformance_receipt.json", "source_selector": "a2a_terminal/raw_tck_result", "source_value": "234 PASS / 1 FAIL", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "234 PASS / 1 FAIL", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e2fdb77127dc38bb", "source_sha256": "e2fdb77127dc38bb8c81d427f3da650c2fe3d2600533a5512be64f73e3c796e1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/protocol_conformance_receipt.json", "source_selector": "a2a_terminal/adjudicated_result", "source_value": "235/235 implementation-conformant", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "235/235 implementation-conformant", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "a2a_implementation", "source_value": "CONFORMANCE_SUBSTANTIVELY_VERIFIED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "CONFORMANCE_SUBSTANTIVELY_VERIFIED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "960387d670958a2e66625c46db63bd6548e1dd36827e38c58ec1c6f43947e6be", "claim_content_hash": "6724631937b6a3c13376f6f76b536e674c0c69460f4ed6fbd28cb9339c32c020" }, { "claim_id": "boundary.public_api", "claim_type": "security_boundary", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "anonymous public API is a positive allowlist", "object": { "approved_operations": 210, "build": "PASS" }, "maturity": "LIVE", "authority": "spec/public_operations.json", "observation_state": "ENFORCED_FAIL_CLOSED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "rendered each canon cycle", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-1b731932f384a9c2", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "1b731932f384a9c25cd3fb61c783f9fadd491db897728e628e43b8f31d8797a2", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/public-api-allowlist.json", "created_at": "2026-09-21T05:33:04.517632+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.594406+00:00", "canon_epoch": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-1e7ab4281a1b43e2", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "1e7ab4281a1b43e2da93c56c8836ae3f38ed8e8e3290e7893c0a420f2cf6054c", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/public-operations.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T15:28:29.754408+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600079+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "idempotency metadata debt is published, not hidden" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "PASS", "adjudicated_state": "PASS", "state_source": "public-api-allowlist.json build", "human": { "claim": "Only explicitly approved operations are in the public API.", "trust_state": "Build fails closed on any leak; 210 operations approved", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/public-api-allowlist.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/boundary.public_api/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/boundary.public_api/observation_state", "source_value": "ENFORCED_FAIL_CLOSED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "ENFORCED_FAIL_CLOSED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-1b731932f384a9c2", "source_sha256": "1b731932f384a9c25cd3fb61c783f9fadd491db897728e628e43b8f31d8797a2", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/public-api-allowlist.json", "source_selector": "build", "source_value": "PASS", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "PASS", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-1b731932f384a9c2", "source_sha256": "1b731932f384a9c25cd3fb61c783f9fadd491db897728e628e43b8f31d8797a2", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/.well-known/public-api-allowlist.json", "source_selector": "build", "source_value": "PASS", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "PASS", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "5d259db3c5d482961ce4be5cad413fde38886082784719da7f510cd1cb7fa0de", "claim_content_hash": "69272ba221956524b0891ebbdb5a4a1d4f3e4aa8bb5228746e0b5a186115f77e" }, { "claim_id": "security.rate_limit_a2a", "claim_type": "security_control", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "public A2A endpoint is rate limited", "object": "nginx limit_req_zone astranl_api rate=30r/m burst=15 nodelay on location ^~ /a2a/", "maturity": "LIVE", "authority": "nginx policy", "observation_state": "PASS", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "tested 2026-09-04T18:57:39.421716+00:00", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-8cb565f063fc3fc8", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "8cb565f063fc3fc8929c2bb63d1716ee2b56219ce348016d97758eb3ffd151d1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/rate_limit_security_test.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T18:59:31.349707+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600321+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T18:57:39.421716+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "proves enforcement of the policy at that moment, not a capacity guarantee" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "FAIL", "adjudicated_state": "PASS", "state_source": "rate_limit_security_test.verdict_v2", "human": { "claim": "The public A2A endpoint is rate limited by policy.", "trust_state": "16 rapid requests served, 17th limited, recovery after the window", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/rate_limit_security_test.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/security.rate_limit_a2a/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-8cb565f063fc3fc8", "source_sha256": "8cb565f063fc3fc8929c2bb63d1716ee2b56219ce348016d97758eb3ffd151d1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/rate_limit_security_test.json", "source_selector": "verdict_v1_kept", "source_value": "FAIL", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "FAIL", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-8cb565f063fc3fc8", "source_sha256": "8cb565f063fc3fc8929c2bb63d1716ee2b56219ce348016d97758eb3ffd151d1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/rate_limit_security_test.json", "source_selector": "verdict_v2", "source_value": "PASS", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "PASS", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-8cb565f063fc3fc8", "source_sha256": "8cb565f063fc3fc8929c2bb63d1716ee2b56219ce348016d97758eb3ffd151d1", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/rate_limit_security_test.json", "source_selector": "verdict_v2", "source_value": "PASS", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "PASS", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "f6f41dc1074523048b7bbe2de04671a33d1e122a47041c67175aeca2f6aa0a0c", "claim_content_hash": "c811d2a62a53491834f9ef2c6652d7c3322a672cf2fb6443cd95adc590de132d" }, { "claim_id": "truth.contradictions", "claim_type": "negative_evidence", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "known contradictions", "object": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "maturity": "LIVE", "authority": "contradiction ledger", "observation_state": "PUBLISHED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": "2026-09-04T20:48:14.142987+00:00", "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-fa43c156841307dc", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "fa43c156841307dc371bb6ad0fb5396119430d2e3491777f192e8a4018ee9b43", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/contradiction_ledger.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T20:48:14.143606+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600551+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [ "C133-08", "C133-11", "E133-07", "E133-13" ], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T20:48:14.142987+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "adjudicated_state": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "state_source": "contradiction_ledger.summary", "human": { "claim": "AstraNL publishes its own contradictions.", "trust_state": "4 still open or index-stale: C133-08, C133-11, E133-07, E133-13", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/contradiction_ledger.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/truth.contradictions/maturity", "source_value": "LIVE", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "LIVE", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/truth.contradictions/observation_state", "source_value": "PUBLISHED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "PUBLISHED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-fa43c156841307dc", "source_sha256": "fa43c156841307dc371bb6ad0fb5396119430d2e3491777f192e8a4018ee9b43", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/contradiction_ledger.json", "source_selector": "summary", "source_value": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-fa43c156841307dc", "source_sha256": "fa43c156841307dc371bb6ad0fb5396119430d2e3491777f192e8a4018ee9b43", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/contradiction_ledger.json", "source_selector": "summary", "source_value": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": { "EXTERNALLY_CONVERGED": 1, "INDEX_STALE_KNOWN": 1, "M5_CANDIDATE_DISPOSITION_NOT_REQUIRED_BY_OBSERVED_LOAD": 1, "OPEN": 2, "OPEN_OUTSIDE_DECISION_133": 1, "PARTIAL": 1, "RECORDED": 1, "RESOLVED": 9, "RESOLVED_AT_ORIGIN_AND_PUBLIC_FETCH": 5, "RESOLVED_NOT_REPRODUCED_AFTER_CURRENT_EPOCH": 1, "RESOLVED_ON_CORE_SURFACES": 2 }, "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 5, "previous_revision_hash": "f86992e9217daf041b733c9e2f83e573516b6d6587d75ed6e450857c61e3c31d", "claim_content_hash": "1de8ebf56d4b3528303eddd417db2d6250b4661ae70baef4780e46aba06abf21" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven.capacity_at_scale", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "operates at scale", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_PROVEN", "authority": "P0.5 bundle not_proven_by_this", "observation_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "bundle", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600662+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "no load evidence beyond the rate-limit policy test" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "state_source": "p05_evidence_bundle.not_proven_by_this", "human": { "claim": "Not proven: AstraNL operates at scale.", "trust_state": "no load evidence beyond the rate-limit policy test", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.capacity_at_scale/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.capacity_at_scale/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "7ba4f6e480a4d0613c7360e49d18e2b6e7275111da0879dee4f636b107228c6e", "claim_content_hash": "086ad81c67f4a0cba130189fdac56eb5dfa9b874757e812b2cd1027530d7a4a0" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven.third_party_certification", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "is certified by a third party", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_PROVEN", "authority": "P0.5 bundle not_proven_by_this", "observation_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "bundle", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600742+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "no certification exists; the A2A proof is self-run against the official TCK" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "state_source": "p05_evidence_bundle.not_proven_by_this", "human": { "claim": "Not proven: AstraNL is certified by a third party.", "trust_state": "no certification exists; the A2A proof is self-run against the official TCK", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.third_party_certification/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.third_party_certification/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "5741824aaa1f70fbf9b474ca040ff0ae66db4ce32a4b6d7af68fada3a4127813", "claim_content_hash": "d81b7756c5338e80fbf84eb1b93dd1882b9173aa35120d3c88582df288976519" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven.economic_outcome", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "produces repeatable paid settlements", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_PROVEN", "authority": "P0.5 bundle not_proven_by_this", "observation_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "bundle", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600799+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "honest zero counters" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "state_source": "p05_evidence_bundle.not_proven_by_this", "human": { "claim": "Not proven: AstraNL produces repeatable paid settlements.", "trust_state": "honest zero counters", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.economic_outcome/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.economic_outcome/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "68cb367d81a274a14653f1b5ed8b9d54fe06928454a408dc80cf36bfca5f2657", "claim_content_hash": "c63760f6f32772eaa09bc70cb342fe82eb2e0c94fe6c5e4a7529acbc80856fa4" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven.autonomous_execution", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "executes real work without founder initiation", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_PROVEN", "authority": "P0.5 bundle not_proven_by_this", "observation_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "bundle", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.600982+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "no autonomy-labelled case has a machine-checkable lifecycle" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "state_source": "p05_evidence_bundle.not_proven_by_this", "human": { "claim": "Not proven: AstraNL executes real work without founder initiation.", "trust_state": "no autonomy-labelled case has a machine-checkable lifecycle", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.autonomous_execution/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.autonomous_execution/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "29f7a56395fbe14ade292bdb8b3c394a3fc939edb34d07c48be4d71cf8b2ad9b", "claim_content_hash": "9593e22452f361b6cf6017b225014ecff5731431f6d2748b1747e7c6ace89c07" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven.robot_execution_capacity", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "routes work to operator-backed machines", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_PROVEN", "authority": "P0.5 bundle not_proven_by_this", "observation_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "bundle", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.601039+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "catalogue only; registered operators 0" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_PROVEN", "state_source": "p05_evidence_bundle.not_proven_by_this", "human": { "claim": "Not proven: AstraNL routes work to operator-backed machines.", "trust_state": "catalogue only; registered operators 0", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.robot_execution_capacity/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven.robot_execution_capacity/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_PROVEN", "transformation": "projection:membership_marker", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "cb71bb2af2c2b1a2dcb97ef940c4d88734734765e69c63227f473081da135d87", "claim_content_hash": "acbb028f5f87169553e50f9d94f5023465dc9649b70606e4b8c124656a7d7166" }, { "claim_id": "human_comprehension", "claim_type": "limitation", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "is understood by a first-time human reader", "object": null, "maturity": "NOT_TESTED", "authority": "no comprehension test run", "observation_state": "NOT_TESTED", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "PROOF_CORRECTNESS is not HUMAN_COMPREHENSION; the two are separate claims" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "NOT_TESTED", "adjudicated_state": "NOT_TESTED", "state_source": "decision 133 P1 status", "human": { "claim": "Whether these pages are understandable to a first-time reader has not been tested.", "trust_state": "NOT_TESTED", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/claims.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/human_comprehension/maturity", "source_value": "NOT_TESTED", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "NOT_TESTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/human_comprehension/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_TESTED", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "NOT_TESTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/human_comprehension/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_TESTED", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "NOT_TESTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/human_comprehension/observation_state", "source_value": "NOT_TESTED", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "NOT_TESTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true } ], "claim_revision": 1, "previous_revision_hash": null, "claim_content_hash": "264d681a781af3948673b7b4f968394973e9bcb57b23292b4c476595fc9f859b" }, { "claim_id": "proof_correctness", "claim_type": "mechanism", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "renders claims without altering their states", "object": { "may": [ "store", "index", "link", "validate schema", "check evidence refs exist", "detect technical inconsistency" ], "may_not": [ "determine truth", "raise maturity", "derive verified from evidence count", "drop an unknown", "turn PARTIAL into success" ] }, "maturity": "IMPLEMENTED", "authority": "core/claim_registry.py law + integrity check", "observation_state": "PROJECTION_EXTERNALLY_OBSERVED_CONSISTENT", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-73e7a981e77913d7", "evidence_type": "source", "content_sha256": "73e7a981e77913d707f20332d627e0927ba57279bdd89bc931dd7331aa4e04a0", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/core/claim_registry.py", "created_at": "2026-09-14T16:43:36.959640+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.601689+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" }, { "evidence_id": "ev-2322936e5339dacd", "evidence_type": "independent_observation", "content_sha256": "2322936e5339dacd64c868d86b9abe27959f4b620d7f53a338ec67e345b0f250", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/claims_external_observation.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:32:40.034669+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.601726+00:00", "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00" } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.590544+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [], "limitations": [ "the observation receipt is for the previous render of /data/claims.json, since this render includes the receipt itself; each render is observed on the next cycle" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "IMPLEMENTED", "adjudicated_state": "IMPLEMENTED", "state_source": "claims_external_observation.json (independent observer receipt); the registry copies the receipt verdict", "human": { "claim": "This page decides nothing; every state is copied from its source.", "trust_state": "External-path fetch 2026-09-04T19:21 (a separate network path, not an audit): bytes identical to origin True, claims hash recomputed True, 6 evidence files hash-matched", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/claims_external_observation.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/proof_correctness/maturity", "source_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/proof_correctness/maturity", "source_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/proof_correctness/maturity", "source_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "IMPLEMENTED", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-2322936e5339dacd", "source_sha256": "2322936e5339dacd64c868d86b9abe27959f4b620d7f53a338ec67e345b0f250", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/claims_external_observation.json", "source_selector": "evidence_all_match", "source_value": true, "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "PROJECTION_EXTERNALLY_OBSERVED_CONSISTENT", "transformation": "projection:receipt_verdict", "equal": null } ], "claim_revision": 3, "previous_revision_hash": "2f1dd1bcc97a5988daf78ff04da5f9da4f8a801ab7540b8e2a2daa5a1e4682ab", "claim_content_hash": "e743dcde853176328f143bd6407e31c475a4f910f752acdd377c38cd64f5cf94" }, { "claim_id": "not_proven", "claim_type": "projection", "subject": "AstraNL", "predicate": "not proven by any current evidence", "object": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "maturity": "PROJECTION", "authority": "P0.5 bundle", "observation_state": "PROJECTION", "execution_state": "n/a", "settlement_state": "n/a", "freshness_state": null, "source_refs": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "evidence_type": "file", "content_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "created_at": "2026-09-04T19:14:28.822052+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-21T05:48:10.601894+00:00", "canon_epoch": null } ], "evidence_refs": [], "contradiction_refs": [], "canon_epoch": "2026-09-21T05:48:09.997137+00:00", "observed_at": "2026-09-04T19:00:31.458742+00:00", "valid_from": null, "valid_until": null, "unknowns": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "limitations": [], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "raw_state": "PROJECTION", "adjudicated_state": "PROJECTION", "state_source": "projection over not_proven.* claims", "human": { "claim": "What AstraNL has not proven yet.", "trust_state": "market adoption, demand, economic volume, repeatable paid settlements, autonomous execution, robot execution capacity", "see_evidence": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json" }, "reconciliation": [ { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven/maturity", "source_value": "PROJECTION", "claim_field": "maturity", "claim_value": "PROJECTION", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-c8bc27a60ca668d2", "source_sha256": "c8bc27a60ca668d214130cac620b1f59a6426e1107a2e990e409a3f8c9635446", "source_location": "/opt/astranl/spec/claim_adjudications.json", "source_selector": "claims/not_proven/observation_state", "source_value": "PROJECTION", "claim_field": "observation_state", "claim_value": "PROJECTION", "transformation": "copy", "equal": true }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "raw_state", "claim_value": "PROJECTION", "transformation": "projection:aggregate_of not_proven.capacity_at_scale,not_proven.third_party_certification,not_proven.economic_outcome,not_proven.autonomous_execution,not_proven.robot_execution_capacity", "equal": null }, { "evidence_id": "ev-e5a8290a141a720b", "source_sha256": "e5a8290a141a720bb9fb38fc199b10b8ef391ee371fc07b2200570935bca7016", "source_location": "https://astranl.com/data/p05_evidence_bundle.json", "source_selector": "not_proven_by_this", "source_value": [ "market adoption", "demand", "economic volume", "repeatable paid settlements", "autonomous execution", "robot execution capacity" ], "claim_field": "adjudicated_state", "claim_value": "PROJECTION", "transformation": "projection:aggregate_of not_proven.capacity_at_scale,not_proven.third_party_certification,not_proven.economic_outcome,not_proven.autonomous_execution,not_proven.robot_execution_capacity", "equal": null } ], "projection_inputs": [ "not_proven.capacity_at_scale", "not_proven.third_party_certification", "not_proven.economic_outcome", "not_proven.autonomous_execution", "not_proven.robot_execution_capacity" ], "claim_revision": 2, "previous_revision_hash": "e4b8a60315cfac0b782a57096c74dbf87827fa0c837c3df2d43320a9364813f8", "claim_content_hash": "9357fcbd75acd16ab3d1bf190aa984cff8f1676031c2161ed8e934727469d39d" } ], "schema": "claim v1 (decision 133 P1)", "claims_sha256": "34431a895b42c29d18d3c59d29421eeb161cee8a5d8cf9e445cb4eeaf3534caf" }